On 11 November the European Commission adopted its proposal for a Digital Fairness Act. It is the centrepiece of a consumer package that also includes a Simplification Directive and a revision of the regulation on cooperation between consumer enforcement authorities. The Commission describes the package as the most significant upgrade of EU consumer protection legislation in over 20 years.
It is a proposal, not law. It now goes to the European Parliament and the Council, and the text will change on the way. But the draft is specific enough to plan around, and several of its rules land directly on work agencies and in-house teams do every week: influencer campaigns, checkout design, subscription flows and, newly, AI agents that shop on a customer's behalf.
A regulation, not a directive
The most consequential choice is the legal form. The draft is a regulation that would repeal the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive of 2005. A directive is transposed by each member state in its own words; a regulation applies directly and identically in all of them. For a business selling across the EU, that means one rulebook instead of 27 national versions of it.
The draft says it would apply 12 months after entry into force. Enforcement stays largely with national authorities, which set the penalties. The Commission's press release adds that the package's revision of the CPC Regulation would give it direct enforcement powers in large-scale cases, with fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover, and a requirement for non-EU businesses that target EU consumers to appoint a representative in the EU.
Influencer marketing: fixed labels and shared responsibility
Article 11 is the part most marketers will feel first. The draft defines influencer marketing as a commercial practice in which traders use their popularity among an audience to promote products in exchange for payment, and it sets out what that means in practice.
- Disclosure must be clear, prominent and unambiguous, and made explicit for each commercial communication using the terms advertisement or commercial collaboration.
- On online platforms covered by the Digital Services Act, disclosure must use the platform's own commercial-content functionality.
- Influencers may not directly urge minors to buy, or to persuade adults to buy for them, and may not suggest a product suits minors when it does not.
- Influencer marketing of products that may not be advertised to consumers, or of dangerous products, is prohibited.
- Any trader using influencer marketing services must ensure, by contract or other appropriate means, that the influencer complies.
That last point is the change for brands. Under the draft, the brief, the contract and the approval process become the brand's evidence that it took compliance seriously. The recitals make clear the rules apply whatever form payment takes, including gifted products and invitations. A creator brief that says "tag us" and leaves disclosure to the creator would no longer be enough.
Dark patterns, personalisation and pricing
Article 10 prohibits designing or operating an online interface in a way that is likely to deceive or manipulate consumers or otherwise materially distort their decisions, and an annex lists dark patterns that are always unfair. The Commission's factsheet gives fake scarcity claims as an example. Countdown timers that reset, "only 2 left" messages that are not true and pre-ticked upsells are the obvious candidates for an audit.
On personalisation the draft is narrower than some campaigners wanted. Article 12 bans targeting ads based on profiling where the trader knows with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor, or where the profiling uses special categories of personal data such as health or religion. Article 13 bans profiling-based personalised prices likely to harm minors or consumers the trader knows to be vulnerable. Neither article requires a business to collect more data to find out who is a minor.
Subscriptions, free trials and a human to talk to
- Free trials: before a trial ends, the trader must send a clear reminder of the end date, the price and how to cancel. Without that reminder, or without the consumer's express agreement to continue, the consumer is not bound by the paid contract.
- Automatic renewals: reminders before contracts roll over, and an online termination function.
- Customer service: where a trader offers online customer service after a sale, a human must be available on request when other means are not effective.
The free-trial rule deserves attention from anyone running acquisition through trials. As drafted, a trial that converts silently would not create a paid contract at all. The fix is not difficult, but it touches billing, email and the sign-up flow, so it is better designed in than retrofitted.
AI agents that buy on a consumer's behalf
Article 26 is new territory. It covers traders that offer consumers automated systems able to conclude contracts on their behalf, which describes the shopping agents now appearing in assistants and on retail sites. On first use, the consumer must choose whether to confirm every purchase, only some (with criteria such as a maximum price and a time limit), or none. The agent must disclose any payment it receives for proposing a contract, and any conflict of interest, and in that case must ask the consumer to confirm whatever they chose earlier.
For advertisers this connects two things that are usually discussed separately: paid placement inside AI assistants and consumer protection. If a sponsored product inside an agent counts as a payment for proposing a contract, the draft would require the agent to ask before buying it. The draft also bars traders from forcing consumers to use an agent to buy on their own website.
The proposal sits alongside the separate EU KIDS Act, which covers under-18s across many of the same practices, and it reaches any business selling to EU consumers, including UK businesses with EU customers. Most of what it asks for is good practice already. The difference is that, if adopted, it would be one directly applicable rule with an EU-level enforcer behind it.
Sources
- https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/consumer-protection-law/digital-fairness-act_en
- https://commission.europa.eu/document/download/0575d59f-554f-4a9e-b54b-e6b717175809_en?filename=Proposal+for+a+Digital+Fairness+Act.pdf
- https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_26_2407



